Study: No Direct Correlation Between COVID-19, Transit System Useeditor@aashto.org October 2, 2020 0 COMMENTS
A new report compiled by the Sam Schwartz transportation-engineering firm on behalf of the American Public Transportation Association indicates that there is “no direct correlation” between use of urban public transit and transmission of the COVID-19 virus.
[Above photo by the MBTA.]
The 35-page report – entitled Public Transit and COVID-19 Pandemic: Global Research and Best Practices – analyzed the latest scientific evidence on how the COVID-19 virus spreads compared to ridership and infection rates in multiple U.S. cities, as well as the impact of various mitigation measures for controlling viral spread. Its analysis found no direct links between transit and infection rates.
“A review of studies from around the world indicate minimal risk from using public transit, especially where specific safeguards are in place, such as face coverings, well-functioning ventilation systems, and minimal talking by riders,” the report said.
The firm added that analysis of public transit ridership in multiple cities over the past three months also shows no correlation with the rise or fall of local COVID-19 cases – underscoring that COVID-19 case rates are tied primarily to local community spread versus public transit ridership rates.
The report also cited case studies from several states to back up that analysis. In Hartford, Connecticut, public transit ridership remained nearly constant in recent months, while overall COVID-19 cases declined. Also, despite more than 150 million rides occurring on New York City subways and buses between June 1 and August 18, the positive test result rate for COVID-19 dropped by 70 percent: declining from a 3.3 percent positive rate to 1 percent.
The report cited several possible explanations for the lack of correlation between public transit ridership and COVID-19 cases:
- Public transit riders generally talk little while using public transit. Scientists have linked many clusters to bars, indoor restaurants, and houses of worship where loud talking and singing may occur.
- Many urban public transit systems feature “enhanced airflow “compared to other indoor locations, as ventilation systems run efficiently and doors frequently open and close.
- Time spent exposed to an infected person impacts the likelihood of infection. Many intra-urban trips are of relatively short duration. In San Francisco, California, Salt Lake City, Utah, Columbus, Ohio, and Austin, Texas, public transit ridership remained mostly constant in recent months yet COVID-19 cases skyrocketed.
The APTA also launched a national “Health and Safety Commitments Program” for transit agencies during a virtual event on September 9 – a safety program designed to assure passengers that public transit systems are “taking all the necessary measures to operate safely” as the nation recovers from the COVID-19 pandemic.
“The program [we’ve] launched is the public transportation industry’s pledge to promote sensible policies and practices designed to keep transit users and transit employees safe during the COVID-19 crisis,” explained Paul Skoutelas, APTA’s president and CEO, during the virtual event.